This week, Kailey and Brayden take you through the twists and turns of the mysterious Chicago Tylenol Murders of 1982. From medical mystery to deadly poisoning; listen to find out more!Sources:

Today Kailey tells the story of one of Boston's greatest mysteries. In the early hours of March 18th, 1990 Boston was settling down after the annual St. Patrick's Day celebrations when something devious was underway in the Fenway district. This...

Kailey returns for season three on the spookiest day of the year!  To kick the new season off Kailey tells us about crucial new updates in the Natalee Holloway case in today's mini episode. Tune in next Tuesday for a full length case that ...

Today Kailey gives you a quick update on the Lady of the Dunes case. Before you listen make sure to listen to the full case in Season 1 Episode 7. If you have any information concerning this case, please contact the FBI's Toll-Free t...

Happy Halloween spooky babes! Today Kailey is joined by fellow podcaster and cousin Miranda; the host of Mother Pucking Murder. The girls chat about Alton's first Unitarian Church and the ghost town known as Dogtown. 

Kicking off spooky season on a light note with his survivor's tale. Katie Beers was only 9 years old when she was kidnapped and kept in a homemade dungeon behind her captures wall for 17 days. Listen to Kailey walk us through the case of Katie ...

Back to our regularly scheduled programming just in time for dinner with Armin Meiwes (as long as we remain the dinner guest that is, and not the main course). Today we are joined by Brayden as our case brings us to Germany where we talk about ...

Kailey is back from vacation and hitting you with a tale of survival. Today's case is about 13 year old Jayme Closs and how she survived 88 days in captivity after her family was murdered. Sources:

Hi guys!! This week Kailey keeps it light and fun with a little bit of spooky. Kailey reads three terrifying first hand encounters from people that shared their personal stories on the subreddit LetsNotMeet on Reddit. 

Welcome back! Today Kailey walks us through the triple homicide, double kidnapping, and sole survivor case that took place in Idaho and how an 8 year old girl led police to the arrest of serial killer Joseph Edward Duncan III. ...

Heidi Planck a 39 year old mother in LA vanished after her son's football game. Kailey walks us through all the details of this eerie disappearance. If you or anyone you know has information regarding this case or the whereabouts of Heidi pleas...

Happy Monday spooky cult! This week Kailey tells the case of the mysterious double homicide of 17 year old best friends, JB Beasley and Tracie Hawlett. An arrest has been made but do we believe they're the ones responsible for the crime? <...

Joined by Brayden, Kailey walks us through the countless strange happenings inside the infamous Bridgewater Triangle.  This episode includes all things supernatural; from UFO and Bigfoot sightings to satanic cults and murder. You name it t...

This week we switched it up and let Brayden take over to tell us the eerie tale of D.B Cooper. D.B. Cooper was a plane hijacker back in the 1970s. This case leaves you with more questions than answers and sounds like something straight out of a...

After a week off, Kailey walks us through the gruesome yet incredible story of survivor, Mary Vincent. Mary was just a 15 year old girl when she was viciously attacked while trying to hitchhike home after running away. Mary's story is bone chil...

In this weeks mini episode Kailey fights through her cold to tell you the stories of two young girls that were murdered in eerily similar ways only eight years apart. New episodes every Wednesday! 

Welcome back spooky kings and queens! What better way to start off season 2 than with America’s most prolific serial killer. In this episode Kailey walks you through key details and events of Sam Little’s life who for decades left people won...

This week the girls share their own creepy encounters ranging from being followed home, Red Sox paparazzi and sexting from your boss. We want to thank all of you for listening and being a part of this podcast. It wouldn't be what it is without ...

Hi guys! This week we connected with Alma and Amanda from the International Hearts Foundation, which is a foundation that helps stop and prevent human trafficking in Mexico and the United States. Alma founded the organization and throughout her...

"It could never happen to me.” A question we tell ourselves way more often than we should. This week we invited Jenn Lee from the Podcast “I Need Blue” onto our show to share her story of when she was held as a hostage at gunpoint, the traum...

Veterans are those who sacrifice their lives for our own, so what happens when a serial killer targets men in uniform, in a place that they’re supposed to feel safe after returning home from war? This week Kelsie walks us through a local case w...

What was once lost is now found. Kailey walks us through a local case that was a missing person’s case all up until this year! The remains of Judith Chartier were found less than a month ago and we thought there were a lot of questions befor...

We took the Kill & Tell Coffee Corner to a whole new level this week as we have our first guest for Coffee Corner! This week we sit down with Kenzie, owner of Flamingo’s Coffee Bar in Hampton Beach, New Hampshire and we talk all things coff...

Oh man, back to our home state of Massachusetts this week. This week Kelsie zooms us over to a small town not too far away from our neck of the woods, where Philip Chism committed a brutal act of violence on his teacher, in school, while other ...

Things are about to get real weird this week, which means pack your bags because the case we’re covering is out of this world! Or, they’re trying to be. Kailey walks us through our first case on cults. Heaven’s Gate, though tragic, was a cul...